Book Of the Day: The Puppet Masters Robert Heinlein 1951
Now that the COVID-19 pandemic is on the back burner, let’s take a look at the response thus far.
The first response was social distancing, intended to slow the spread of the disease enough to give medical facilities a chance to recover from the initial onslaught of cases. That was pretty well sorted by the end of April, and up until that time the strategy was containment.
Well, no one has been talking containment since early May, so that strategy has failed. Now the strategy is slowing the spread through the use of masks. And still social distancing. Now, Asia has been wearing masks for decades during flu season, because Asia is crowded, and social distancing isn’t an option. One is as effective as the other, but you don’t need both. Medical staff don’t gown up and then stand six feet away from the patient. What we have now is a society where everyone masks up and then stands away from each other. It looks, and is, ridiculous.
The more so because we’ve moved from the goal of containment to the process of mitigation. Politicians love them some process, because it is open-ended. You don’t have to commit to a definite end. In my own state of Oregon, the Governor has said she won’t permit full socialization until there is a cure or vaccine for COVID-19. Unless an effective vaccine appears in the next couple of months, and it likely won’t (trials, etc), that’s not a practical approach.
In a mitigation process, you have to determine when you’ve mitigated enough. That is, at what point is the danger low enough to end the preventive measures. If you are in government, the answer is “Never!”, but we will confine ourselves to the real world.
One metric for societal impact is incidence per 100,000 population. As of 9 June 2020 the statewide average stands at 118/100k. That sounds high, but represents a known infection rate of 0.1%. One tenth of one percent. If cases were evenly distributed throughout the population, you would have to be in a space with 1,000 people to be assured that one person had COVID-19.
So at what point is the risk of infection low enough? And even if infected, outside of narrow demographic ranges, the average person is sick for a bit and recovers. If there are complications, there are adequate medical facilities. COVID-19 is less lethal than a myriad of other diseases we don’t seem too worried about, let alone completely disrupting society. There are presumably highly-trained people who can estimate these things, but if they have some answers, they have not been forthcoming.
Nor has government been quick to rescind restrictions. One might think the loss of tax revenue alone would prompt government to lift proscriptions, but as time passes, bureaucrats and politicians seem ever more comfortable with the situation, as are Nanny State fellow travelers. I’ve noted that people generally aren’t good at assessing risk unless trained, making the situation ripe for exploitation. That 0.1% incidence rate? You don’t see that number bandied about. It’s a lot more about how everyone needs to be ‘socially responsible’. Because the thing with masks is that they don’t protect me from you, they protect you from me.
‘Socially responsible’ usually means ‘I want to control you’. Given that COVID-19 is fatal to a very small and defined population, and appears to be losing lethality, the vasty great majority of people are putting up with a not insignificant inconvenience. In itself this isn’t bad; a society should look out for its own, but it appears we are at the point of masks as social obligation more than effective mitigation.
In a pandemic people view others as a death threat. Probably the way the rest of the world views Americans. Everyone has a gun. Everyone is mistrustful, suspicious, on edge. And this is not irrational at the height of a pandemic. But not wearing a mask is perceived as putting others in danger. If they believe in the mask, they fear you. These days, by simply not wearing a mask, a person gains power. This makes people nervous. But they probably won’t physically attack you, because, you know, social distancing.
“Hey! Where’s your mask?!”
“Come say that to my face.”
But the mask thing didn’t gain traction during the height of the pandemic when it would have been most effective, and a likely more enthusiastic participation. While masks were recommended in early April, the public wasn’t really encouraged until mid-May, when the pandemic had started to ebb.
There are people who view masks as a form of social control, and I can’t say they are wrong. Want to ride mass transit? Wear a mask. Want to travel on a commercial conveyance? Wear a mask. Go into some businesses? Wear a mask. Enter a government building? You get the idea. It’s a version of the Chinese social credit system.
Which we also find ourselves past the intersection of the ‘COVID-19 Danger’ and ‘Societal Response’ curves, which puts us in ‘Mass Hysteria’ territory. This is sort of expected, as December through March were marked by ever-more breathless news reports on mass deaths from the Wuhan Whirlwind. The public perception curve started steep, and has lost considerable steam, but while flattening, isn’t yet declining.
I’m hopeful the decline will start soon, in the form of more people edging social distancing and not wearing masks. I’m trying to bring back handshakes. My clients of late don’t know from social distancing.
COVID-19 is real, is dangerous, and should be treated with respect. But it’s not a Biblical Plague, or even Marburg’s or Ebola. A lot of people have died from the disease, but the concern is for the living. As a human being, and an American, I refuse to live in fear.
Craft Project
While I had a minimum of unscheduled time off in March, work has been busy. But I have made time to work on my craft project, and look to finish this summer. I’m pretty happy with it, and it does provide much-needed diversion.
Word Watch
I was reading a hobby forum, and a regular contributor used the word ‘mensurations’. The gentleman’s native language is not English, and it was clear from context he meant ‘measurements’, but I wondered if ‘mensuration’ is a word in English.
It is. ‘The measuring of geometric magnitudes, lengths, areas, and volumes.’
The word is from the Latin (no surprise there), and usage appears to have peaked prior to 1880 (the internet is great!). And for such an obscure word, there are videos! The things you can learn.
On The Radio
Because there are no sports, I have returned to listening to the local classical and jazz stations. There are some very good programs on the jazz station. One that stands out is Jukebox Saturday Night, program by a local host that features music from the swing, jazz, and pop (with a little gospel) from the 30’s – 50’s. Of course, programming now is all over the map as far as what you’ll hear. KMHD is not doing live programming. Classical station KQAC is, so go figure.
Some years ago I had a job in Ft. Polk, Louisiana. The location allowed trips to New Orleans (Nawlins), and on one trip we had the project manager along. A native Texan married to a Louisianan, she related how corrupt the Louisiana State government was. Tens of millions of dollars had ‘disappeared’ from the New Orleans school district. She laughed it off, as corrupt politics is business-as-usual in Louisiana. And not surprised, as I read Richard White’s Kingfish along with everyone else in high school.
Fast-forward to Hurricane Katrina, and corrupt government isn’t so much a laughing matter. You can look it up. And so we have a similar problem now.
Because facing a pandemic, successfully, requires united effort. Also some metrics, but we’ll leave that alone. There is a bit of a problem in that Progressives have spent decades preaching division, and now that unity is needed, there’s none to be had. How can you tell people to unite in common cause, when you have based your power on division? Why should I care about someone who makes my life more difficult?
And that’s a corrupted system. One in which even the supporters don’t care. It’s not that the system as designed is flawed, but if you add stuff and add stuff, the system will collapse. And that’s kind of where we’re at. You can see the pieces crumbling off. Tower of Babel and all.
A nation is constituted to unify people to a common cause. The American common cause of liberty and freedom is still alive; you just have to look to protests in Hong Kong to see them. Currently, there’s a paucity of the same in their homeland.
Driving Around
Escape!
(Also an excellent Journey album).
I had the Brand ‘Y’ tires on the Mazda replaced with Brand ‘G’ (not the blimp folks). As the tires were under the 30-day guarantee, it was a straight swap. The new tires have a higher speed rating, so stiffer sidewalls.
Yes.
No flexing in corners. The suspension isn’t fighting the tires. The car is much more predictable. I’m still figuring out where the suspension/tire limit is, and a cautious experiment on public roads, but certainly in the ‘fun’ zone.
Leave a Comment
Posted in Commentary, Driving, Society | Tags: Commentary, Society